Select Renovations logo
Blog Layout

Comparing Metal Roofs: Steel vs. Aluminum

Select Renovation • September 5, 2024

When selecting the right material for your metal roofing project, the debate between steel and aluminum often takes center stage. Both materials offer unique advantages, and choosing the best one for your building in Fraser, Michigan, requires careful consideration. It’s important to stay informed when deciding on metal roofs, like steel vs. aluminum.At Select Renovations , we aim to give business owners the knowledge they need to make an informed decision. This comprehensive guide will compare steel and aluminum roofing, helping you decide which material best suits your needs.

What Is Metal Roofing?

Metal roofing is a popular choice for both residential and commercial buildings due to its durability, energy efficiency, and long-lasting performance.

These roofs are made from various materials, including steel, aluminum, zinc, and copper . Each metal roofing material has its own set of characteristics, making it essential to choose the right one based on your specific needs and environment.

Types of Metal Roofing

Metal roofing comes in several styles and other materials , including:

  • Standing Seam Metal Roofing : Features vertical panels with raised seams that interlock to prevent water penetration.
  • Metal Shingles : Mimic the appearance of traditional shingles but with the durability of metal.
  • Corrugated Metal Roofing : Known for its wavy appearance, it is often used in industrial and agricultural buildings.

At Select Renovations, we specialize in installing and repairing these types of metal roofing in Fraser, Michigan , helping business owners enhance their properties’ curb appeal and longevity.

What Is Aluminum Roofing?

Aluminum metal roofing is lightweight and corrosion-resistant, making it a popular choice for coastal regions or areas with high humidity. This material is known for its ability to withstand harsh weather conditions without rusting or deteriorating.

Aluminum roofing is also energy-efficient, reflecting more sunlight and reducing cooling costs during the summer months. It has several benefits, including:

  1. Corrosion Resistance : Aluminum does not rust, making it ideal for environments exposed to moisture, saltwater, and corrosive environments.
  2. Lightweight : Easier to install and less strain on the building structure.
  3. Energy Efficiency : Reflects heat, reducing energy costs.
  4. Recyclability : Aluminum is 100% recyclable, making it an eco-friendly choice.

However, aluminum roofing does come with some drawbacks. For example, it is generally more expensive than steel, and its lightweight nature can make it less resistant to impact damage from heavy objects like falling branches.

What Is Steel Roofing?

Steel is the most commonly used roofing product, known for its strength, durability, and cost-effectiveness.

Steel is heavier than aluminum and can withstand more impact, making it a great choice for areas prone to hail or heavy snowfall. It is often coated with a zinc or aluminum-zinc alloy layer to enhance its corrosion resistance. The benefits of steel roofing are:

  1. Durability : Steel is extremely strong and can last for decades with proper maintenance.
  2. Cost-Effectiveness : Generally more affordable than aluminum, offering great value for money.
  3. Versatility : Available in a wide range of styles, including standing seam metal roofs and metal shingles.
  4. Fire Resistance : Steel is non-combustible, providing an added layer of safety.

On the downside, steel roofing is prone to rust if not properly coated, and it can be heavier, which may require additional structural support during installation.

Pros and Cons of Aluminum and Steel Roofing

Here is a helpful table comparing both types of roofing materials:

Type of Metal Roof Pros Cons
Aluminum Roofing -Corrosion resistant
-Easy to install and handle
-High reflective; reduces cooling costs
-Eco-friendly and fully recyclable		 -More expensive than steel
-Less durable under heavy impact
-Fewer color and customization options
Steel Roofing -Can withstand severe weather conditions
-More affordable than aluminum
-Comes in various colors and finishes
-Fire resistant		 -Susceptible to rust and corrosion
-Heavier weight, may require additional installation support
-Absorbs more heat and can increase cooling costs

When Should You Use Aluminum Roofing vs. Steel Roofing?

Choosing between aluminum and steel roofing depends on various factors, including your location, budget, and specific needs.

Galvalume roofing mild steel is anti-rust and durable
galvanized steel roofing sheets in warehouse
Aluminum Roofing
In coastal and humid areas because of corrosion resistance
If you want to save on energy costs and cooling efforts
For buildings that may not support the weight of steel
Steel Roofing
If you want something budget-conscious and get your value for money
If you live in an area with heavy winds, snow, or hail
Want more style options

Conclusion

Both aluminum and steel roofing materials offer significant advantages , and the choice between them depends on your specific needs, budget, and location. At Select Renovations, we’re here to help Fraser, Michigan, business owners make the best decision for their properties. 

Whether you need a durable steel roof to withstand harsh weather or a lightweight, corrosion-resistant aluminum roof, our team has the expertise to ensure the success of your roofing project.

Let us help you protect your investment with a roofing solution that meets your needs and exceeds your expectations. Call us today!

A roof with a lot of shingles on it

How Often Should You Inspect Your Roof? Seasonal Roof Inspection Tips for Homeowners

By Select Renovation • December 17, 2024
The post How Often Should You Inspect Your Roof? Seasonal Roof Inspection Tips for Homeowners appeared first on SELECT RENOVATIONS.
A red roof and a green roof are sitting next to each other.

Shingle or Metal Roof? Roofing Options for Climate

By Select Renovation • December 17, 2024
When choosing a roof for your home, the decision can feel overwhelming. With so many options available, it’s important to focus on one key factor: your local climate. The roof over your head needs to do more than just look good—it must protect your home against the elements. Whether you’re drawn to the classic look […] The post Shingle or Metal Roof? Roofing Options for Climate appeared first on SELECT RENOVATIONS.
A man wearing a hard hat and safety harness is standing on a roof.

Impact of Roofing and Home Resale Value: What Homeowners Need to Know

By Select Renovation • November 13, 2024
When it comes to increasing a home’s value, many people think of kitchen remodels or bathroom upgrades, but one major factor often overlooked is roofing. In fact, roofing and home resale value are more connected than most homeowners realize. The condition and quality of your roof can significantly affect your home’s appeal, attract potential buyers, […] The post Impact of Roofing and Home Resale Value: What Homeowners Need to Know appeared first on SELECT RENOVATIONS.
A close up of a roof with a hole in it

Roofing Problems You Can’t Ignore: 6 Red Flags That Signal Urgent Repairs

By Select Renovation • November 13, 2024
When it comes to your home, the roof over your head plays a big role in protecting everything. But sometimes, we miss the early signs that our roof may be struggling, and ignoring these roofing problems can lead to expensive repairs. If you want to avoid headaches and keep your home in great shape, look […] The post Roofing Problems You Can’t Ignore: 6 Red Flags That Signal Urgent Repairs appeared first on SELECT RENOVATIONS.
An aerial view of a roof of a house.

How to Inspect Your Roof for Hail Damage: A Guide for Homeowners

By Select Renovation • September 30, 2024
After a hailstorm, your roof might look fine from the ground, but even small hailstones can cause significant damage that isn’t always visible. Hail damage can lead to costly repairs or even a full roof replacement if left unchecked. In this guide, Select Renovations will walk you through how to inspect your roof for hail […] The post How to Inspect Your Roof for Hail Damage: A Guide for Homeowners appeared first on SELECT RENOVATIONS.
A man is walking up a ladder on a roof.

What Do Roof Inspectors Look For?

By Select Renovation • September 30, 2024
Roof inspections are one of the most important maintenance tasks for homeowners and businesses, especially in a place like Fraser, MI, where the weather can be unpredictable. With harsh winters that bring heavy snow, ice, and wind, along with spring rains and summer storms, your roof takes a beating throughout the year. These weather conditions […] The post What Do Roof Inspectors Look For? appeared first on SELECT RENOVATIONS.
A man is sitting on top of a tiled roof.

How to Stop Roof Leaks: A Guide by Select Renovations

By Select Renovation • September 5, 2024
Roof leaks are a common issue many homeowners and business owners face, particularly in areas like Fraser, Michigan, where the weather can be unpredictable. A leaky roof can lead to severe water damage, structural issues, and even health hazards if not addressed promptly.  At Select Renovations, we understand the urgency of stopping roof leaks and […] The post How to Stop Roof Leaks: A Guide by Select Renovations appeared first on SELECT RENOVATIONS.
A close up of a copper tile roof

The Complete Guide to Aged Copper Roof

By Select Renovation • July 29, 2024
Are you thinking about installing a copper roof in your home? This guide is meant to help. Learn all you need to know about the advantages of an aged copper roof, a popular choice among homeowners because of its durability and aesthetics. In this guide, Select Renovations will explore everything about aged copper roofs, including […] The post The Complete Guide to Aged Copper Roof appeared first on SELECT RENOVATIONS.
A close up of a roof with a blue sky in the background

Metal Roof vs. Shingles in Hot Climate: Which Frets Better?

By Select Renovation • July 29, 2024
Choosing the right roof for your home in Fraser, Michigan, can be challenging, especially in hot places. In this post, Select Renovations will explore the pros and cons of metal roofs vs. shingles in hot climates. We’ll dive into the types of metal and shingle roofs, how each performs in high temperatures, cost considerations, environmental […] The post Metal Roof vs. Shingles in Hot Climate: Which Frets Better? appeared first on SELECT RENOVATIONS.
Share by: